University of Minnesota Event Explores Jewish Identity and Indigenous Ties to Israel

The University of Minnesota chapter of Students Supporting Israel hosted Lani Anpo for a conversation on the connection between Jewish identity and indigeneity. 

Lani Anpo, a Jewish Native American woman, explained the national frameworks used to understand indigeneity – and to apply those standards to the Jewish people. 

Growing up, Anpo felt close to her indigenous identity, but often faced pushback when she described herself as both Jewish and Native American. An ancestry test later revealed that not only was her dad Jewish, but her mother had Jewish ancestry she did not know about. 

Anpo shared that she often received online hate where she was accused of being a Zionist and a colonialist. 

“I know enough to know that Jews are indigenous to Israel,” said Anpo in response to the criticism. 

This experience, combined with the events of October 7, made Anpo want to study the relationship between Indigenous identity and the people of Israel 

During her presentation, Anpo explained that indigeneity is more complex than ancestry and birthplace. International frameworks consider a multitude of factors such as historical continuity, a people’s relationship to ancestral territory, cultural traditions, and self-identification. 

“Indigenous means historical continuity with a distinct people,” said Anpo. “A distinct pre-invasion society, one that maintains its relationship to a specific territory and its own social, legal, and cultural systems.” 

Anpo explained that there is a difference between being native to a place and being indigenous. While someone may be born in a region, indigeneity involves having self-identification and a society with its own cultural values and traditions. 

“Self-identification is fundamental, but it isn’t enough on its own,” said Anpo. 

Anpo then applied these frameworks to the Jewish people, using the examples of archaeological findings, historical records, and evidence of ancient Israeli kingdoms. 

“Jews didn’t arrive in Canaan. Israel emerged from it,” said Anpo when explaining that the Israelites developed as a distinct people in the land of Israel. 

Anpo also shared that genetic studies can be used to show evidence of ancestral connections. However, Anpo argued that DNA alone doesn’t determine one’s indigeneity. 

“Genetics can tell us where Jews come from, but it’s the peoplehood, a continuous people, with its own law, language, and relationship to the land and culture that tells us who Jews are,” said Anpo. 

Anpo argued that the Jewish people’s identity and connection to Israel have formed through thousands of years of history. 

Anpo encouraged the audience to look beyond basic definitions of indigeneity. Rather, it is critical to consider cultural and historic experiences of people who identify with the land and have experienced displacement and assimilation.